By DealShore Motors
Last September in France, the industry’s catch-all “other brands” line — the one where Chinese manufacturers get counted — hit 9.67% market share, roughly double a year earlier. MG alone registered 25,550 cars in France in the first nine months of 2026; BYD registered 22,667. A market that was a curiosity three years ago is now the fastest-growing segment of the French car market.
And the question every buyer is asking, usually with a skeptical tilt of the head: are these things actually reliable, or are we all about to learn an expensive lesson together?
Here’s what the data says — not the marketing, not the forum folklore, the actual published numbers. And since this site’s rule is brutal honesty: the data says it depends entirely on which brand’s badge is on the nose.
The Invasion, by the Numbers
Chinese-brand registrations in France, January–September 2026 (via Journal de l’Automobile):
| Brand | Registrations | Market share |
|---|---|---|
| MG | 25,550 | 2.1% |
| BYD | 22,667 | 1.8% |
| Jaecoo | 9,618 | 0.8% |
| Leapmotor | 5,902 | 0.5% |
| XPeng | 5,513 | 0.4% |
| Geely | 1,002 | — |
| Omoda | 820 | — |
MG’s trajectory tells the story: 0% market share in 2017, 1.4% in 2024, 2.1% in 2025 — and in 2025 MG France passed 100,000 cumulative vehicles sold, finishing as the 14th brand in France with ~60% of sales going to private buyers (not fleets). These are real customers spending real money, not subsidized demo fleets.
But sales volume tells you a car is cheap and available. It tells you nothing about whether it breaks. For that, we need the surveys.
What the Owner Surveys Say: Two Completely Different Stories
The strongest European owner survey of 2026 is the Altroconsumo/consortium survey of 53,000 motorists across 10 countries (reported September 2026). It puts Chinese brands at opposite ends of the table:
- BYD: 89/100 — level with Honda, Tesla, Smart, Mazda, Mitsubishi and Kia. Behind Lexus (93) and Toyota/Suzuki/Subaru (91), but squarely in the Japanese-tier reliability bracket.
- MG: 72/100 — second-to-last, ahead of only Land Rover (64).
That’s the headline, and it carries an important lesson: brand matters more than country of origin. “Chinese car” is not one reliability category. BYD and MG are as different as Toyota and Land Rover.
The UK’s What Car? Reliability Survey adds the MG turnaround story — and it’s dramatic. In the 2024 survey, MG finished dead last at 76.9%, and the MG4 was the least-reliable EV in the survey at 63.8%. In the 2026 survey, MG jumped to 9th overall at 92.0% — the most-improved manufacturer in the survey. The MG S5 EV scored 98.3%, the best electric SUV rating in the survey. The MG4 specifically rated 89.3% (2025 survey data): a 27% fault rate, with non-engine electrics (8%), infotainment (7%) and interior trim (5%) the most common complaints — and 100% of repairs done free. One in five faults was the battery pack itself, at 3%.
Meanwhile Warranty Solutions Group’s July 2026 analysis of ~2,500 real UK EV warranty claims found the MG ZS EV with a 2.33% claim rate — among the best EVs in the sample (the Renault Zoe led at 1.49%; the Tesla Model S was worst at 34%).
A pattern is emerging: MG’s early cars were rough, and MG’s recent cars are getting much better, fast.
What owners say (paraphrased from owner forums and owner polls — these are recurring themes, not cherry-picked quotes):
- The mechanical drivetrain — motors, batteries, running gear — is consistently described as robust. Breakdowns of the actual EV hardware are rare.
- The #1 complaint category is the software: infotainment with no physical buttons for basic functions, confusing menus, driver-assist alerts that must be re-disabled at every startup.
- The #2 complaint is aftersales: long waits for servicing appointments and very long waits for spare parts when they’re needed.
- After dealer software updates, some owners report charging bugs (cars refusing DC rapid charging), fixed by a further update — and some dealers installing outdated software versions.
The Drivetrain Is Not the Problem
This is worth stating clearly, because it’s the fear most buyers carry: the electric drivetrain in these cars — the thing that would be catastrophically expensive to fix — is the most reliable part of them. ADAC’s 2025 breakdown data found EVs registered 2020–2022 suffered 4.2 breakdowns per 1,000 vehicles versus 10.4 for combustion cars. Electric cars simply have fewer things to break, and that structural advantage applies to MG and BYD exactly as it applies to Tesla and Hyundai.
When these cars “fail,” they fail on software polish and service logistics — annoying, sometimes expensive in lost time, but a different universe from an engine or transmission failure.
The Warranty Card: the Longest in Europe, and It’s Not Close
If Chinese brands were unsure of their reliability, they’d be selling short warranties. They do the opposite. Compare what’s officially offered in France:
| Brand | Vehicle warranty | Battery warranty | Anti-corrosion |
|---|---|---|---|
| MG | 7 years / 150,000 km | 7 years / 150,000 km (70% capacity floor) | per terms |
| BYD | 6 years / 150,000 km | 8 years / 250,000 km (70% SoH floor) | 12 years, unlimited km |
| Renault | 2 years / 100,000 km | 8 years / 160,000 km | 12 years |
| Peugeot | 2 years | 8 years / 160,000 km | 12 years |
| Hyundai | 5 years / unlimited km | 8 years / 200,000 km | 12 years |
MG’s 7-year vehicle warranty is the longest of any brand sold in Europe. BYD’s 8-year/250,000 km Blade battery warranty — extended in January 2026 and applied retroactively to existing European owners — is the strongest battery warranty on the continent, full stop.
Is a long warranty proof of reliability? No. But it is a bet the company’s money signal. Warranties are priced by actuaries who see the actual failure data. MG and BYD are writing the biggest warranty checks in Europe, which means their own actuaries believe the cars will hold up.
Crash Safety: Five Stars — With One Caveat
On crash safety, the data is unambiguous: Euro NCAP awarded 5 stars to the MG4 (2022), the MG ZS EV, the BYD Dolphin, the BYD Seal and the BYD Atto 3. The MG4 scored 83% adult occupant, 80% child; the Atto 3 scored 91% adult, 89% child. On structural crashworthiness, these are genuinely competitive cars.
The caveat — and the brutal-honesty part: in September 2026, the Asian-market MG ZS scored 0 stars in Taiwan’s NCAP, with doors that stayed locked and a side airbag that failed to deploy. That was a Taiwan-spec car, not the European ZS, and you cannot legally or logically transfer that rating to French-market cars. But it’s a warning worth keeping: specs vary by market, and a 5-star badge on one continent’s car is not a 5-star badge on another’s. Check the Euro NCAP rating for the exact model and spec you’re buying.
The Two Recalls You Should Know About
MG3, France, 2026: France’s official recall register (rappel.conso.gouv.fr, published 27 March 2026) lists the MG3 and MG3 Hybrid+: in certain collisions, the driver’s seat can shift involuntarily after impact. MG’s fix is free at the dealer — Euro NCAP publicly flagged the issue and MG’s response was described as robust. If you own an MG3, get the fix. It’s free and it matters.
BYD, September 2024: 96,714 Dolphin and Yuan Plus (the Atto 3’s Chinese-market name) were recalled in China for a defective electric power-steering controller — a capacitor that could crack and, in theory, short-circuit. BYD and its distributors stated this recall covered China domestic vehicles only, not European cars. No European BYD recall has been issued for this issue.
A word on recalls in general: a recall is not proof a car is bad — mature brands issue them constantly. But for a young brand with a young dealer network, every recall is also a test of that network’s maturity. That’s the part to watch.
What We Can’t Tell You (Because Nobody Has It)
Honesty cuts both ways, so here’s what the data doesn’t include yet:
- There are no verified per-model ADAC Pannenstatistik breakdown rates for the MG4 or MG ZS in the officially published tables. If a blog hands you a neat ranking, it’s working from thin secondary sources, not ADAC’s data.
- There are no MG or BYD entries in the TÜV Report rankings — current generations are too recent for long-term German inspection data.
- No published French-language fiabilité survey (L’Automobile Magazine, L’Argus, Auto Plus) has covered MG or BYD yet.
Anyone quoting you TÜV defect rates for an MG4 is inventing them. Don’t trust that site for anything else, either.
The Honest Verdict
So: are Chinese cars in France reliable? The 2026 data says BYD is already there — Japanese-tier survey scores, the strongest battery warranty in Europe, 5-star crash ratings. MG is mid-turnaround — rough early years, one of the steepest improvement curves ever recorded in the What Car? survey, the longest warranty in Europe as a confidence signal, but owner complaints about software polish and parts wait times persist. The newer and smaller brands (Jaecoo, Leapmotor, XPeng, Omoda) simply don’t have enough data yet — too few cars, too few years.
If you’re buying one: check the dealer network near your address (this matters more for MG than for anything else), insist on every software update before delivery, and on a used MG4 or Atto 3, check the battery state of health like you’d check the service history on a combustion car.
Buying Used? Scan It First
Before you hand over money for a used MG4, BYD Dolphin or any other EV — Chinese or not — plug in an OBD-II scanner and read the fault memory and battery data. It takes five minutes and it catches the cars the seller “forgot” to tell you about: cleared codes, battery degradation, modules with stored faults. Our own guide to using an OBD2 scanner walks you through the whole check.
DealShore pick: OBDLink MX+ Bluetooth OBD-II scanner — the research-backed pick for pre-purchase scans: reads live data and fault codes on iOS and Android, no subscription. Perfect for the 5-minute used-EV check above.
When you buy through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Journal de l’Automobile, ~2 Oct 2026: Chinese-brand registrations in France Jan–Sept 2026 — https://journalauto.com/constructeurs/comment-les-marques-chinoises-font-leurs-ventes-en-france/
- MotorsActu, Sept 2026: Altroconsumo 53,000-motorist European survey (BYD 89/100, MG 72/100) — https://motorsactu.com/fiabilite-marques-chinoises-europe-donnees/
- What Car? Reliability Survey 2026 (via electriccarsreport.com, Oct 2026): MG 9th at 92.0%, MG S5 EV 98.3% — https://electriccarsreport.com/2026/10/mg-motors-reports-record-september-as-uk-sales-reach-new-quarterly-high/
- What Car? MG4 89.3% rating, 27% fault rate — https://www.whatcar.com/news/reliability-survey-most-reliable-electric-cars/n26158
- cardealermagazine.co.uk, Oct 2024: MG last in 2024 survey at 76.9% — https://cardealermagazine.co.uk/mg-named-the-most-unreliable-used-car-brand-as-top-10-worst-manufacturers-revealed
- Fleet News, 15 July 2026: Warranty Solutions Group EV claim data (MG ZS EV 2.33%) — https://www.fleetnews.co.uk/news/warranty-firm-names-most-and-least-reliable-evs-based-on-claims-data
- MG Motor EU official: 7-year/150,000 km warranty — https://news.mgmotor.eu/fr/press/mg-etend-la-garantie-constructeur-a-7-ans/
- BYD France official: warranty terms incl. 8-year/250,000 km Blade battery — https://www.byd.com/fr/entretien-et-reparation/Garantie-constructeur
- Rappel.conso.gouv.fr, 27 March 2026: MG3/MG3 Hybrid+ seat recall — https://rappel.conso.gouv.fr/affichettepdf/49461/rapex
- Carscoops, May 2026: Euro NCAP MG3 seat finding — https://www.carscoops.com/2026/05/mg3-seat-recall/
- Fleet News: Euro NCAP 5-star ratings for BYD Dolphin/Seal — https://www.fleetnews.co.uk/news/latest-byd-models-score-top-marks-in-euro-ncap-safety-test
- mgevs.com: MG4 owner-reported issues (infotainment, charging bugs, parts) — https://www.mgevs.com/tags/recall/
- electricroad.co.uk, Sept 2026: MG4 owner poll on infotainment/parts complaints — https://electricroad.co.uk/2026/09/mg4-ev-real-world-review-range-costs/
Data current as of October 2026. Registration figures are France, January–September 2026. Survey results cited are UK/European — the closest published equivalents to French owner data, since no French fiabilité survey has covered these brands yet.

Leave a Reply